Total 4731 registered members
Siemens technical publication | Loss Of Vacuum

Siemens technical publication | Loss Of Vacuum

If a vacuum interrupter should lose vacuum, several operating situations should be considered:

1. With contacts open
2. When closing
3. When closed and operating normally
4. When opening and interrupting normal current
5. When opening and interrupting a fault.

Cases 1, 2 and 3 are relatively straightforward. Generally, the system sees no impact from loss of vacuum in such a situation. Cases 4 and 5, however, require further discussion. Suppose there is a feeder circuit breaker with a vacuum interrupter on phase 3 that has lost vacuum. If the load being served by the failed interrupter is a deltaconnected (ungrounded) load, a switching operation would not result in a failure. Essentially, nothing would happen. The two good phases (phase 1 and phase 2, in this example) would be able to clear the circuit, and current in the failed interrupter (phase 3) would cease.

The alternative case of a grounded load is a different situation. In this case, interruption in the two good phases (phase 1 and phase 2) would not cause current to stop flowing in phase 3, and the arc would continue to exist in phase 3. With nothing to stop it, this current would continue until some backup protection operated. The result, of course, would be destruction of the interrupter.

Since the predominant usage of circuit breakers in the 5-15 kV range is on grounded circuits, we investigated the impact of a failed interrupter some years ago in the test lab. We intentionally caused an interrupter to lose vacuum by opening the tube to the atmosphere. We then subjected the circuit breaker to a full short circuit interruption. As predicted,
the “flat” interrupter did not successfully clear the affected phase, and the “flat” interrupter was destroyed. The laboratory backup breaker cleared the fault. Following the test, the circuit breaker was removed from the switchgear cell. It was very sooty, but mechanically intact. The soot was cleaned from the circuit breaker and the switchgear cell, the faulty interrupter was replaced, and the circuit breaker was re-inserted in the cell. Further short circuit interruption tests were conducted the same day on the circuit breaker.

Field experience in the years since that test was conducted supports the information gained in the laboratory experiment. One of our customers, a large chemical operation, encountered separate failures (one with an air magnetic circuit breaker and one with a vacuum circuit breaker) on a particular circuit configuration. Two different installations, in different countries, were involved. They shared a common circuit configuration and failure mode. The circuit configuration, a tie circuit in which the sources on each side of the circuit
breaker were not in synchronism, imposed approximately double rated voltage across the contact gap, which caused the circuit breaker to fail. Since these failures resulted from application in violation of the guidelines of the ANSI standards, and greatly in excess of the design ratings of the circuit breakers, they are not indicative of a design
problem with the equipment.

However, the damage that resulted from the failures is of interest. In the case of the air magnetic circuit breaker, the unit housing the failed circuit breaker was destroyed, and the adjacent switchgear units on either side were damaged extensively, requiring significant rebuilding. The air magnetic circuit breaker was a total loss. In the case of the vacuum circuit breaker, the failure was considerably less violent. The vacuum interrupters were replaced, and the arc by-products (soot) cleaned from both the circuit breaker and the compartment. The unit was put back into service. Our test experience in the laboratory, where we routinely explore the limits of interrupter performance, also supports these results.

More recently, several tests were performed in our high-power test laboratory to compare the results of attempted interruptions with “leaky” vacuum interrupters. A small hole (approximately 1/8” diameter) was drilled in the interrupter housing, to simulate a vacuum interrupter that had lost vacuum.

The results of these tests were very interesting:

  1. One pole of a vacuum circuit breaker was subjected to an attempted interruption of 1310 A (rated continuous current = 1250 A). The current was allowed to flow in the “failed” interrupter for 2.06 seconds, at which point the laboratory breaker interrupted. No parts of the “failed” circuit breaker or the interrupter flew off, nor did the circuit breaker explode. The paint on the exterior of the interrupter arcing chamber peeled off. The remainder of the circuit breaker was undamaged.
    .
  2. A second pole of the same vacuum circuit breaker was subjected to an attempted interruption of 25 kA (rated interrupting current = 25 kA), for an arc-duration of 0.60 seconds, with the laboratory breaker interrupting the current at that time. The arc burned a hole in the side of the arc chamber. The circuit breaker did not explode, nor did parts of the circuit breaker fly off. Glowing particles were ejected from the hole in the arcing chamber. None of the mechanical components or other interrupters were damaged. Essentially, all damage was confined to the failed interrupter.

Our experience suggests rather strongly that the effects of a vacuum interrupter failure on the equipment are very minor, compared to the impact of failures with alternative interruption technologies. But the real question is not what the results of a failure might be, but rather, what is the likelihood of a failure? The failure rate of Siemens vacuum interrupters is so low that loss of vacuum is no longer a significant concern. In the early 1960s with early vacuum interrupters, it was a big problem. A vacuum interrupter is constructed with all connections between dissimilar materials made by brazing or welding. No organic materials are used. In the early years, many hand-production techniques were used, especially when borosilicate glass was used for the insulating envelope, as it could not tolerate high temperatures. Today, machine welding and batch induction furnace brazing are employed with extremely tight process control. The only moving part inside the interrupter is the copper contact, which is connected to the interrupter end plate with a welded stainless steel bellows. Since the bellows is welded to both the contact and the interrupter end plate, the failure rate of this moving connection is extremely low. This accounts for the
extremely high reliability of Siemens vacuum interrupters today.

In fact, the MTTF (mean time to failure) of Siemens power vacuum interrupters has now reached 24,000 years (as of October 1991). Questions raised by customers regarding loss of vacuum were legitimate concerns in the 1960s, when the use of vacuum interrupters for power applications was in its infancy. At that time, vacuum interrupters suffered from frequent leaks, and surges were a problem. There was only one firm that offered vacuum circuit breakers then, and reports suggest that they had many problems. We entered the vacuum circuit breaker market in 1974, using Allis-Chalmers’ technology and copper-bismuth contact materials. In the early 1980′s, after becoming part of the worldwide Siemens organization, we were able to convert our vacuum designs to use Siemens vacuum interrupters, which had been introduced in Europe in the mid-1970s. Thus, when we adopted the Siemens vacuum interrupters in the U.S., they already had a very well established field performance record.

The principle conceptual differences in the modern Siemens vacuum interrupters from the early 1960s designs lies in contact material and process control. Surge phenomena are more difficult to deal with when copper-bismuth contacts are used than with today’s chromecopper contacts. Similarly, leaks were harder to control with vacuum interrupters built largely by hand than with today’s units. Today, great attention is paid to process control and elimination of the human factor (variability) in manufacture. The result is that the Siemens vacuum interrupters today can be expected to have a long service life and to impose dielectric stress on load equipment that is not significantly different from the stresses associated with traditional air magnetic or oil circuit breakers.

.

Published by: SIEMENS AG

.

Related articles

8DN8 switchgear for rated voltages up to 72.5 kV

8DN8 switchgear for rated voltages up to 145 kV

A fundamental feature of Siemens gas-insulated switchgear is the high degree of versatility provided by its modular system. Depending on their respective functions, the components are housed either individually and/or combined in compressed gas-tight enclosures. With a remarkably small number of active and passive modules, all customary circuit variants are possible. Sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) is used as the insulating and arc-quenching medium.
Three-phase enclosures are used for type 8DN8 switchgear in order to achieve extremely low component dimensions. This concept allows a very compact design with reduced space requirement. Aluminium is used for the enclosure. This assures freedom from corrosion and results in low weight of the equipment. The use of modern construction methods and casting techniques allows optimizing the enclosure’s dielectric and mechanical character- istics. The low bay weight ensures minimal floor loading and eliminates the need for complex foundations.

All the modules are connected to one another by means of flanges. The gastightness of the flange connections is assured by proven O-ring seals. Temperature-related changes in the length of the enclosure and installation tolerances are compensated by bellows-type expansion joints. To that end, the conductors are linked by coupling contacts. Where necessary, the joints are accessible via manway openings.

Gas-tight bushings allow subdivision of the bay into a number of separate gas compartments. Each gas compartment is provided with its own gas monitoring equipment, a rupture diaphragm, and filter material. The static filters in the gas compartments absorb moisture and decomposition products. The rupture diaphragms prevent build-up of an im- permissible high pressure in the enclosure. A gas diverter nozzle on the rupture diaphragm ensures that the gas is expelled in a defined direction in the event of bursting, thus ensuring that the operating personnel is not endangered.

Three-phase enclosure allows compact design

Three-phase enclosure allows compact design

8DN8 switchgear parts

8DN8 switchgear parts (click to see large)

Circuit-breaker module

The central element of the gas-insulated switchgear is the three-pole circuit-breaker module enclosure comprising the following two main components:

  • Interrupter unit
  • Operating mechanism

The design of the interrupter unit and of the operating mechanism is based on proven and in most cases identical designs, which have often been applied for outdoor switchgear installations.

Operating mechanism

The spring-stored energy operating mechanism provides the force for opening and closing the circuit-breaker. It is installed in a compact corrosion- free aluminium housing. The closing spring and the opening spring are arranged so as to ensure good visibility in the operating mechanism block. The entire operating mechanism unit is completely isolated from the SF6 gas compartments. Anti-friction bearings and a maintenance-free charging mechanism ensure decades of reliable operation.
Proven design principles of Siemens circuit-breakers are used, such as vibration-isolated latches and load-free decoupling of the charging mechanism. The operating mechanism offers the following advantages:

  • Defined switching position which is securely maintained even if the auxiliary power supply fails
  • Tripping is possible irrespective of the status of the closing spring
  • High number of mechanical operations
  • Low number of mechanical parts
  • Compact design
Three-position switching device
Positions

Positions

The functions of a disconnector and an earthing switch are combined in a three-position switching device. The moving contact either closes the isolating gap or connects the high-voltage conductor to the fixed contact of the earthing switch. Integral mutual inter- locking of the two functions is achieved as a result of this design, thus obviating the need for providing corresponding electrical interlocking within the switchgear bay. An insulated connection to the fixed contact of the earthing switch is provided outside the enclosure for test purposes. In the third neutral position neither the disconnector contact nor the earthing switch contact is closed. The three poles of a bay are mutually coupled and all the three poles are operated at once by a motor. Force is transmitted into the enclosure via gas-tight rotating shaft glands. The check-back contacts and the on-off indicators are mechanically robust and are connected directly to the operating shaft. Emergency operation by hand is possible. The enclosure can be provided with inspec- tion windows, in the case of which the “On” and “Off” position of all three phases is visible.

Outgoing feeder module

The outgoing feeder module connects the basic bay with various termination modules (for cable termi- nation, overhead line termination and transformer termination). It contains a three-position switching device, which combines the functions of an outgoing feeder disconnector and of a bay-side earthing switch (work-in-progress type). Installation of a high-speed earthing switch and of a voltage transformer is also possible where required. The high-voltage site testing equipment is generally connected to this module.

Busbar module

Connections between the bays are effected by means of busbars. The busbars of each bay are enclosed. Adjacent busbar modules are coupled by means of expansion joints. The module contains a three-position switching device, which combines the functions of a busbar disconnector and of a bay-side earthing switch (work-in-progress type).

Bus sectionalizers

Bus sectionalizers are used for isolating the busbar sections of a substation. They are integrated in the busbar in the same manner as a busbar module. The module contains a three-position switching device, which combines the functions of a bus sectionalizer and of an earthing switch (work-in-progress type).

High-speed earthing switch

The high-speed earthing switch used is of the so-called “pin-type”. In this type of switch, the earthing pin at earth potential is pushed into the tulip-shaped fixed contact. The earthing switch is equipped with a spring-operated mechanism, charged by an electric motor.

Proven switchgear control

All the elements required for control and monitoring are accommodated in a decentralized arrangement in the high-voltage switching devices. The switching device control systems are factory-tested and the switchgear is usually supplied with bay-internal cabling all the way to the integrated local control cubicle. This minimizes the time required for com- missioning and reduces the possibilities of error.
By default, the control and monitoring system is implemented with electromechanical components. Alternatively, digital intelligent control and pro- tection systems including comprehensive diagnos- tics and monitoring functions are available. More detailed information on condition of the substation state permits condition-based maintenance. This consequently reduces life cycle costs even further.

Gas monitoring

Each bay is divided into functionally distinct gas compartments (circuit-breaker, disconnector, voltage transformer, etc.). The gas compartments are con- stantly observed by means of density monitors with integrated indicators; any deviations are indicated
as soon as they arrive at the defined response thresh- old. The optionally available monitoring system includes sensors that allow remote monitoring and trend forecasts for each gas compartment.

Flexible and reliable protection in bay and substation control

Control and feeder protection are generally accom- modated in the local control cubicle, which is itself integrated in the operating panel of the switchgear bay. This substantially reduces the amount of time and space required for commissioning. Alternatively, a version of the local control cubicle for installation separate from the switchgear is available. Thus, different requirements with respect to the arrange- ment of the control and protection components are easy to meet. The cabling between the separately installed local control cubicle and the high-voltage switching devices is effected via coded plugs, which minimizes both the effort involved and the risk of cabling errors.
Of course we can supply high-voltage switchgear with any customary bay and substation control equipment upon request. We provide uniform systems to meet your individual requirements.

Left: Spring-stored energy operting mechanism; Right: Integrated local control cubicle

Left: Spring-stored energy operting mechanism; Right: Integrated local control cubicle

Neutral interfaces in the switchgear control allow interfacing

  • conventional control systems with contactor interlocking and control panel
  • digital control and protection comprising user- friendly bay controllers and substation auto- mation with PC operator station (HMI)
  • intelligent, uniformly networked digital control and protection systems with supplementary monitoring and telediagnostics functions.

Given the wide range of Siemens control and protection equipment, we can provide customized concepts with everything from a single source.

Technical Data
.Switchgear type.8DN8
.Rated voltage.72.5 / 145 kV
.Rated frequency.50 / 60 Hz
.Rated power frequency withstand voltage (1 min).140 / 275 kV
.Rated lightning impulse withstand voltage (1.2/50 μs).325 / 650 kV
.Rated normal current busbar
.Rated normal current feeder
.2500 / 3150 A
.2500 / 3150 A
.Rated short-breaking current.31.5 / 40 kA
.Rated peak withstand current.85 / 108 kA
.Rated short-time withstand current.31.5 / 40 kA
.Leakage rate per year and gas compartment.≤ 0.5 %
.Bay width.650/800/1200 mm
.Height, depth.see typical bay arrangements
.Driving mechanism of circuit-breaker.stored-energy spring
.Rated operating sequence.O-0.3 s-CO-3 min-CO
.CO-15 s-CO
.Rated supply voltage.60 to 250 V DC
.Expected lifetime.> 50 years
.Ambient temperature range.–30 / –25 °C up to +40 °C
.Standards.IEC / IEEE
Operation and maintenance

Siemens gas-insulated switchgear is designed and manufactured so as to achieve an optimal balance of design, materials used and maintenance required. The hermetically-sealed enclosures and automatic monitoring ensure minimal switchgear mainte- nance: The assemblies are practically maintenance- free under normal operating conditions. We re- commend that the first major inspection be carried out after 25 years.

.

Related articles

Na stranici Stručni programi su postavljeni linkovi za download programa za specificiranje srednjenaponskih distributivnih postrojenja 8DJ, 8DH i NXPLUS C proizvođača Siemens. Programi koriste jednostavan interfejs i imaju mogućnost kreiranja porudžbina direktno u SAP-u. Postoj predefinisane kombinacije vodnih, trafo, prekidačkih i merne ćelije, kao i export izveštaja, tj. detaljnog crteža sa prednjim izgledom i otvorima za kablove u MS Powerpoint. Grafički deo programa uključuje samo jednostavne izglede jednopolnih šema ćelija, kao i opcija koje te ćelije podržavaju.

Korisni link:

Profix – Concept Finding & Planning / Procurement & Erection

.

Related articles

Book with graphical explanations of short circuit and its calculations (purpose, standards, types, calculations…)

.

Related articles

Brendiranje ePlusMenuCAD-aSvi elementi unutar ePlusMenuCAD-a se mogu “brendirati”. To bi značilo da ti elementi jednoznačno određuju da je u pitanju određeni proizvođač opreme. To može biti Schneider Electric, ABB, Siemens, Legrand, Schrack, ili bilo koji drugi domaći ili strani proizvođač elektroopreme.

Zašto to raditi?

Proizvođači opreme VRLO dobro znaju da ako hoće da se njihova oprema bude u objektu koji je u planu da se izgradi, da sve počinje od odgovornog projektanta. Dakle, mislim da je vrlo indikativno šta želim da kažem! Ukoliko bi se u tehničkoj specifikaciji ePlusMenuCAD-a našlo ime određenog proizvođača, kao i recimo stvarne dimenzije ili karakteristike opreme – to bi nesumnjivo bio jedan od prvih koraka implementiranja određene opreme u projekat. Time je otvoren put za dalje…